
Science fiction films live and die by the rules they set for themselves within their stories. However, when a sci-fi feature such as I Am Number Four does not even bother with parameters and skimps on backstory, it enhances the fiction side of the genre, leaving the science on the waste side and an audience apathetic.
John is one of the last of his people from a far-off world trying to conceal his identify on Earth while he is being hunted by another alien species known as Mogadorians, who are responsible for the destruction of his race. John is Number Four of nine extraordinary beings from his planet, all with special abilities that when matured are a threat to the Mogadorians and their conquest to take over Earth.
I Am Number Four plays out like a glorified pilot episode for a CW or SyFy television series. And perhaps that’s what it should have been because it seems writers Alfred Gough and Miles Millar (Smallville) were still in TV mode when writing this screenplay. The backstory on the main characters is thinner than Christian Bale in The Machinist. Stereotypes used for modern day teenagers comes straight out of an 80’s film, and the villain Mogadorians might as well be directly transported from a bad episode of Star Trek.
The main plot line of nine supernatural beings from another planet who are systematically hunted on Earth is not without some merit. The film begins as intriguing but suffers from an incredibly long and drawn out 2nd Act that does little more than waste time with redundant scenes of John receiving text messages on his iPhone. The film does manage to accelerate in the 3rd Act with some exciting action sequences and special effects displaying Johns abilities, but they are merely superficial with zero support in the story of their limitations and how they function.
Alex Pettier who plays John in the film gives an admirable performance with the material he was given. Pettier brings a strong sense of moral stature and confidence to the role, giving the audience a reason to root for John other than just because he’s the good guy. Other notable performances include Diana Agron (Glee) playing John’s human love interest Sarah. Agron possesses the skills of a more seasoned actor which, by no fault of her own, sometime seem out of place among her young cast mates. It’s unfortunate there was not an opportunity for Agron to have any scenes with Timothy Olyphant’s (Live Free or Die Hard, Justified) character Henri, who is also from John’s planet and responsible for his protection until John’s powers come to fruition. Olyphant’s substantial talents are pretty much wasted in this film as the script never gives his character the chance to be the mentor and key to John's backstory that was so desperately needed.
This film has good framework with a story idea and fresh, qualified actors to begin a new sci-fi saga, but its complete lack of depth and attention to detail will ultimately keep I Am Number Four in the class of one-shot and forgotten.
Story: 6.5
Acting: 7.0
Writing: 6.0
Captivation: 6.0
Replay Value: 7.0
Total = 6.5
Member of the Boxxet Network of Blogs, Videos and Photos






