
Staying true to one’s craft may be more important in comedy than any other type of performance art. A comedian must walk the never-ending stage between appeasing their core audience and evolving their material to stay relevant. It would not be an egregious statement to say that Adam Sandler has completely and utterly ignored that concept. Although the "Jerry Lewis" of our time has definitely branched out of his comfort zone with serious and even critically acclaimed roles in “Punch Drunk Love,” “Spanglish” and “Reign Over Me,” the silly meat and inane potatoes that elevated Sandler to superstardom have been in recent danger of turning old and moldy.
To his defense, there really is not an abundant distinction between flops like “Jack and Jill” and successes like “Mr. Deeds.” In that way, Sandler is undervalued as one of the most consistent performers in Hollywood. Critics have hated just about every single comedy he’s produced, even all-time classics like “Happy Gilmore.” But Sandler has stayed loyal to his ample and core audience throughout his career, perhaps even to a fault. The factor that may be moving the “relevant” needle away from Sandler is that the young and vivacious audience that skyrocketed him to “comedy god” status in the late ‘90’s, has grown up. Their taste may have changed with age, and the new generation’s funny bones are not easily tickled by punching out a game show host. So what can he do to keep his fans happy, appeal to the contempo “Apatow” crowd, and evolve as a comedian without pulling an “Eddie Murphy?” With his latest film, “That’s My Boy,” Sandler for the first time turns to a restricted rating to help free up his creativity.
In his early teens, Donny Berger (Adam Sandler) was the “victim” of a sexually aggressive teacher, Ms. McGarricle (Eva Amurri Martino, "Californication"). During their consensual escapades, the two are literally caught with their pants down and Berger immediately becomes a hero for his premature conquest. As Ms. McGarricle gets sentenced to 30 years in prison, now pregnant with an adolescent’s child, Berger becomes an 80’s pop icon; his face splashed on the cover of teen magazines and his life the subject of a “Lifetime” style TV movie. After Berger’s “15 minutes” are up, he finds himself broke and estranged from his son, Todd aka, Han Solo Berger (Andy Samberg, "Saturday Night Live"), who has committed his life to escaping everything and anything to do with his infamous father. When Donny is about to go to prison for tax evasion, he finds an opportunity to exploit himself to make some fast cash, but the deal is contingent on him getting Todd involved.
Adam Sandler has appeared in plenty of R-rated films before, he’s even been a producer on a few comedies under the category, but never has Sandler himself starred in one of his consummate Happy Madison productions beyond the edge of PG-13. In “That’s My Boy,” that fact manifests itself like a kid who just learned his first swear word. Practically every joke is an attempt to shock the audience. Some do achieve this goal while others fall flat, very flat, but that’s not something foreign even to Sandler’s most heralded films. The unfortunate byproduct of delving into new R-rated ground is that “That’s My Boy” is going to be compared to higher quality films of the same class. Sandler can definitely go “toe-to-toe” with the best in the business in terms of pure raunchiness, as anyone who’s ever heard his early Grammy-nominated comedy albums can attest. And even though he can get away with some big laughs surrounding a few surgically added heartfelt moments on the PG-13 level, “That’s My Boy” is severely lacking in terms of strong characters and plot points when compared to films of the same ilk.
As usual the cast is flooded with all of the Happy Madison regulars, but recently Sandler has been growing his band of merry men to include many of the current “Saturday Night Live” cast and a few eclectic “what’s he/she doing in this film” choices as well.
Disappointingly, co-star Andy Samberg, who has been so closely compared to Sandler for the similarity of their names and their musical comedy on SNL, largely plays “Abbott” to Sandler’s “Costello” for most of the film. The idea for a film based on the premise in which Sandler and Samberg portray some kind of inappropriate father/son relationship is definitely intriguing, but by Samberg playing the “straight man,” it neuters part of that appeal as he never really gets a chance to showcase his comedy prowess to what is probably the biggest mainstream audience he’s ever had.
There are plenty of laugh-out-loud moments and although it was definitely entertaining to watch Adam Sandler in a no-holds-barred type of comedy setting, “That’s My Boy” culminates as more of a novelty act, depriving fans of the two co-stars the madcap baton-passing story they rightfully deserved.
Story: 5.0
Acting: 5.0
Writing: 6.0
Captivation: 6.0
Replay Value: 6.0
Total = 5.7 out of 10







